Passage 1: Bats to the rescue
How Madagascar's bats are helping to save the rainforests
You should spend about 20 minutes on Questions 1-13 which are based on Reading Passage 1 below.
There are few places in the world where relations between agriculture and conservation are more strained. Madagascar's forests are being converted to agricultural land at a rate of one percent every year. Much of this destruction is fuelled by the cultivation of the country's main staple crop: rice. And a key reason for this destruction is that insect pests are destroying vast quantities of what is grown by local subsistence farmers, leading them to clear forest to create new paddy fields. The result is devastating habitat and biodiversity loss on the island, but not all species are suffering. In fact, some of the island's insectivorous bats are currently thriving and this has important implications for farmers and conservationists alike.
Enter University of Cambridge zoologist Ricardo Rocha. He's passionate about conservation, and bats. More specifically, he's interested in how bats are responding to human activity and deforestation in particular. Rocha's new study shows that several species of bats are giving Madagascar's rice farmers a vital pest control service by feasting on plagues of insects. And this, he believes, can ease the financial pressure on farmers to turn forests into fields.
Bats comprise roughly one-fifth of all mammal species in Madagascar and thirty-six recorded bat species are native to the island, making it one of the most important regions for conservation of this animal group anywhere in the world.
Co-leading an international team of scientists, Rocha found that several species of indigenous bats are taking advantage of habitat modification to hunt insects swarming above the country's rice fields. They include the Malagasy mouse-eared bat, Major's long-fingered bat, the Malagasy white-bellied free-tailed bat, and Peters' wrinkle-lipped bat.
‘These winner species are providing a valuable free service to Madagascar as biological pest suppressors,’ says Rocha. ‘We found that six species of bat are preying on rice pests, including the paddy swarming caterpillar and grass webworm. The damage which these insects cause puts the island's farmers under huge financial pressure and that encourages deforestation.’
The study, now published in the journal Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment, set out to investigate the feeding activity of insectivorous bats in the farmland bordering the Ranomafana National Park in the southeast of the country.
Rocha and his team used state-of-the-art ultrasonic recorders to record over a thousand bat ‘feeding buzzes’ (echolocation sequences used by bats to target their prey) at 54 sites, in order to identify the favourite feeding spots of the bats. They next used DNA barcoding techniques to analyze droppings collected from bats at the different sites.
The recordings revealed that bat activity over rice fields was much higher than it was in continuous forest – seven times higher over rice fields which were on flat ground, and sixteen times higher over fields on the sides of hills – leaving no doubt that the animals are preferentially foraging in these man-made ecosystems. The researchers suggest that the bats favor these fields because lack of water and nutrient run-off make these crops more susceptible to insect pest infestations. DNA analysis showed that all six species of bat had fed on economically important insect pests. While the findings indicated that rice farming benefits most from the bats, the scientists also found indications that the bats were consuming pests of other crops, including the black twig borer (which infests coffee plants), the sugarcane cicada, the macadamia nut-borer, and the sober tabby (a pest of citrus fruits).
‘The effectiveness of bats as pest controllers has already been proven in the USA and Catalonia,’ said co-author James Kemp, from the University of Lisbon. ‘But our study is the first to show this happening in Madagascar, where the stakes for both farmers and conservationists are so high.’
Local people may have a further reason to be grateful to their bats. While the animal is often associated with spreading diseases, Rocha and his team found evidence that Malagasy bats feed not just on crop pests but also on mosquitoes – carriers of malaria, Rift Valley fever virus and elephantiasis – as well as blackflies, which spread river blindness.
Rocha points out that the relationship is complicated. When food is scarce, bats become a crucial source of protein for local people. Even the children will hunt them. And as well as roosting in trees, the bats sometimes roost in buildings, but are not welcomed there because they make them unclean. At the same time, however, they are associated with sacred caves and the ancestors, so they can be viewed as beings between worlds, which makes them very significant in the culture of the people. And one potential problem is that while these bats are benefitting from farming, at the same time deforestation is reducing the places where they can roost, which could have long-term effects on their numbers. Rocha says, ‘With the right help, we hope that farmers can promote this mutually beneficial relationship by installing bat houses.’
Rocha and his colleagues believe that maximizing bat populations can help to boost crop yields and promote sustainable livelihoods. The team is now calling for further research to quantify this contribution. ‘I'm very optimistic,’ says Rocha. ‘If we give nature a hand, we can speed up the process of regeneration.’
Does education fuel economic growth?
You should spend about 20 minutes on Questions 14-26 which are based on Reading Passage 2 below.
A.
Over the last decade, a huge database about the lives of southwest German villagers between 1600
and 1900 has been compiled by a team led by Professor Sheilagh Ogilvie at Cambridge
University's Faculty of Economics. It includes court records, guild ledgers, parish registers,
village censuses, tax lists and the most recent addition – 9,000 handwritten inventories
listing over a million personal possessions belonging to ordinary women and men across three
centuries. Ogilvie, who discovered the inventories in the archives of two German communities 30
years ago, believes they may hold the answer to a conundrum that has long puzzled economists: the
lack of evidence for a causal link between education and a country's economic growth.
B.
As Ogilvie explains, ‘Education helps us work more productively, invent better technology,
and earn more … surely it must be critical for economic growth? But, if you look back
through history, there's no evidence that having a high literacy rate made a country
industrialise earlier.’ Between 1600 and 1900, England had only mediocre literacy rates by
European standards, yet its economy grew fast, and it was the first country to industrialize.
During this period, Germany and Scandinavia had excellent literacy rates, but their economies grew
slowly, and they industrialized late. ‘Modern cross-country analyses have also struggled to
find evidence that education causes economic growth, even though there is plenty of evidence that
growth increases education,’ she adds.
C.
In the handwritten inventories that Ogilvie is analyzing are the belongings of women and men at
marriage, remarriage, and death. From badger skins to Bibles, sewing machines to scarlet bodices
– the villagers' entire worldly goods are included. Inventories of agricultural equipment
and craft tools reveal economic activities; ownership of books and education-related objects like
pens and slates suggests how people learned. In addition, the tax lists included in the database
record the value of farms, workshops, assets, and debts; signatures and people's estimates of
their age indicate literacy and numeracy levels; court records reveal obstacles (such as the
activities of the guilds*) that stifled industry.
Previous studies usually had just one way of linking education with economic growth – the
presence of schools and printing presses, perhaps, or school enrolment, or the ability to sign
names. According to Ogilvie, the database provides multiple indicators for the same individuals,
making it possible to analyse links between literacy, numeracy, wealth, and industriousness, for
individual women and men over the long term.
*Guild: an association of artisans or merchants which oversees the practice of their craft and trade in a particular area.
D.
Ogilvie and her team have been building the vast database of material possessions on top of their
full demographic reconstruction of the people who lived in these two German communities. ‘We
can follow the same people – and their descendants – across 300 years of educational
and economic change,’ she says. Individual lives have unfolded before their eyes. Stories
like that of the 24-year-olds Ana Regina and Magdalena Riethmullerin, who were chastised in 1707
for reading books in church instead of listening to the sermon. ‘This tells us they were
continuing to develop their reading skills at least a decade after leaving school,’ explains
Ogilvie. The database also reveals the case of Juliana Schweickherdt, a 50-year-old spinster living
in the small Black Forest community of Wildberg, who was reprimanded in 1752 by the local
weavers' guild for ‘weaving cloth and combing wool, counter to the guild
ordinance’. When Juliana continued taking jobs reserved for male guild members, she was
summoned before the guild court and told to pay a fine equivalent to one third of a servant's
annual wage. It was a small act of defiance by today's standards, but it reflects a time when
laws in Germany and elsewhere regulated people's access to labour markets. The dominance of
guilds not only prevented people from using their skills, but also held back even the simplest
industrial innovations.
E.
The data-gathering phase of the project has been completed and now, according to Ogilvie, it is
time ‘to ask the big questions.’ One way to look at whether education causes economic
growth is to ‘hold wealth constant.’ This involves following the lives of different
people with the same level of wealth over a period of time. If wealth is constant, it is possible
to discover whether education was, for example, linked to the cultivation of new crops, or to the
adoption of industrial innovations like sewing machines. The team will also ask what aspect of
education helped people engage more with productive and innovative activities. Was it, for
instance, literacy, numeracy, book ownership, years of schooling? Was there a threshold level
– a tipping point – that needed to be reached to affect economic performance?
F.
Ogilvie hopes to start finding answers to these questions over the next few years. One thing is
already clear, she says: the relationship between education and economic growth is far from
straightforward. ‘German-speaking central Europe is an excellent laboratory for testing
theories of economic growth,’ she explains. Between 1600 and 1900, literacy rates and book
ownership were high and yet the region remained poor. It was also the case that local guilds and
merchant associations were extremely powerful and legislated against anything that undermined their
monopolies. In villages throughout the region, guilds blocked labour migration and resisted changes
that might reduce their influence.
‘Early findings suggest that the potential benefits of education for the economy can be held
back by other barriers, and this has implications for today,’ says Ogilvie. ‘Huge
amounts are spent improving education in developing countries, but this spending can fail to
deliver economic growth if restrictions block people – especially women and the poor –
from using their education in economically productive ways. If economic institutions are poorly set
up, for instance, education can't lead to growth.’
Passage 3: Timur Gareyev – blindfold chess champion
You should spend about 20 minutes on Questions 27-40 which are based on Reading Passage 3 below.
A.
Next month, a chess player named Timur Gareyev will take on nearly 50 opponents at once. But that
is not the hard part. While his challengers will play the games as normal, Gareyev himself will be
blindfolded. Even by world record standards, it sets a high bar for human performance. The
28-year-old already stands out in the rarefied world of blindfold chess. He has a fondness for
bright clothes and unusual hairstyles, and he gets his kicks from the adventure sport of BASE
jumping. He has already proved himself a strong chess player, too. In a 10-hour chess marathon in
2013, Gareyev played 33 games in his head simultaneously. He won 29 and lost none. The skill has
become his brand: he calls himself the Blindfold King.
B.
But Gareyev's prowess has drawn interest from beyond the chess-playing community. In the hope
of understanding how he and others like him can perform such mental feats, researchers at the
University of California in Los Angeles (UCLA) called him in for tests. They now have their first
results. ‘The ability to play a game of chess with your eyes closed is not a far reach for
most accomplished players,’ says Jesse Rissman, who runs a memory lab at UCLA. ‘But the
thing that's so remarkable about Timur and a few other individuals is the number of games they
can keep active at once. To me it is simply astonishing.’
C.
Gareyev learned to play chess in his native Uzbekistan when he was six years old. Tutored by his
grandfather, he entered his first tournament aged eight and soon became obsessed with competitions.
At 16, he was crowned Asia's youngest ever chess grandmaster. He moved to the US soon after,
and as a student helped his university win its first national chess championship. In 2013, Gareyev
was ranked the third best chess player in the US.
D.
To the uninitiated, blindfold chess seems to call for superhuman skill. But displays of the feat go
back centuries. The first recorded game in Europe was played in 13th-century Florence.
In 1947, the Argentinian grandmaster Miguel Najdorf played 45 simultaneous games in his mind,
winning 39 in the 24-hour session.
E.
Accomplished players can develop the skill of playing blind even without realizing it. The nature
of the game is to run through possible moves in the mind to see how they play out. From this,
regular players develop a memory for the patterns the pieces make, the defences and attacks.
‘You recreate it in your mind,’ said Gareyev. ‘A lot of players are capable of
doing what I'm doing.’ The real mental challenge comes from playing multiple games at
once in the head. Not only must the positions of each piece on every board be memorized, they must
be recalled faithfully when needed, updated with each player's moves, and then reliably stored
again, so the brain can move on to the next board. First moves can be tough to remember because
they are fairly uninteresting. But the ends of games are taxing too, as exhaustion sets in. When
Gareyev is tired, his recall can get patchy. He sometimes makes moves based on only a fragmented
memory of the pieces' positions.
F.
The scientists first had Gareyev perform some standard memory tests. These assessed his ability to
hold numbers, pictures, and words in mind. One classic test measures how many numbers a person can
repeat, both forwards and backwards, soon after hearing them. Most people manage about seven.
‘He was not exceptional on any of these standard tests,’ said Rissman. ‘We
didn't find anything other than playing chess that he seems to be supremely gifted at.’
But next came the brain scans. With Gareyev lying down in the machine, Rissman looked at how well
connected the various regions of the chess player's brain were. Though the results are
tentative and as yet unpublished, the scans found much greater than average communication between
parts of Gareyev's brain that make up what is called the frontoparietal control network. Of 63
people scanned alongside the chess player, only one or two scored more highly on the measure.
‘You use this network in almost any complex task. It helps you to allocate attention, keep
rules in mind, and work out whether you should be responding or not,’ said Rissman.
G.
It was not the only hint of something special in Gareyev's brain. The scans also suggest that
Gareyev's visual network is more highly connected to other brain parts than usual. Initial
results suggest that the areas of the brain that process visual images – such as chess boards
– may have stronger links to other brain regions, and so be more powerful than normal. While
the analyses are not finalized yet, they may hold the first clues to Gareyev's extraordinary
ability.
H.
For the world record attempt, Gareyev hopes to play 47 blindfold games at once in about 16 hours.
He will need to win 80% to claim the title. ‘I don't worry too much about the winning
percentage, that's never been an issue for me,’ he said. ‘The most important part
of blindfold chess for me is that I have found the one thing that I can fully dedicate myself to. I
miss having an obsession.’